Sanders echoes Catholic social teaching and Pope Francis: don’t yield to despair and cynicism: a moral economy is not beyond our reach

April 15, 2016

U.S. Democratic presidential hopeful Bernie Sanders embraced decades of Catholic social teaching in a brief visit to the Vatican Friday, lambasting some particularly American aspects of the global market system, matching his voice to Pope Francis’ cry against the “new idols” of money and wealth.

Traveling from the campaign trail and a debate Thursday night in Brooklyn, the Vermont senator spoke to a Vatican meeting just steps away from St. Peter’s Basilica.  With many references to church documents, Sanders lauded Francis’ repeated call to overcome a “globalization of indifference” — labeling it “the most powerful name to the predicament of modern society.”

“I am told time and time again by the rich and powerful, and the mainstream media that represent them, that we should be ‘practical,’ that we should accept the status quo; that a truly moral economy is beyond our reach.  Yet Pope Francis himself is surely the world’s greatest demonstration against such a surrender to despair and cynicism. He has opened the eyes of the world once again to the claims of mercy, justice and the possibilities of a better world. He is inspiring the world to find a new global consensus for our common home.

“The issue of wealth and income inequality is the great economic issue of our time, the great political issue of our time, and the great moral issue of our time.  It is an issue that we must confront in my nation and across the world.”

Sanders was speaking Friday at an event co-hosted by the Vatican’s Pontifical Academy of the Sciences and the Institute for Advanced Catholic Studies on the 25th anniversary of Pope John Paul II’s 1991 encyclical letter Centesimus Annus.

The letter — which at points argues for increased rights for workers and cries against places where they have become become “disposable cogs of the financial system” — was itself written for the 100th anniversary of Pope Leo XIII’s landmark encyclical Rerum Novarum, which is widely considered to be the first document of the church’s social teachings.

Sanders’ presence at the conference has been the source of some controversy, as the pontifical academy’s president, Margaret Archer, initially said the candidate had asked for an invitation to come. But academy chancellor Bishop Marcelo Sanchez Sorondo later clarified that he had invited the candidate.

Questions also surfaced as to whether the senator might meet Francis during the visit. According to normal Vatican protocol, the pontiff usually only meets government officials, not those currently seeking office.

After Sanders entered the academy’s Casina Pio IV, an iconic marble building behind St. Peter’s where the conference is being held, Sanchez Sorondo read a letter aloud to participants from Francis explaining the pontiff could not make the event.

The pope said that his quickly planned trip for Saturday to the Greek island of Lesbos made it too difficult to make room in his schedule.

The intense media interest in Sanders’ visit left the Vatican rather unprepared Friday, with several correspondents who have long been in Rome denied entry into the city-state due to apparent miscommunication over who would be allowed in.

After the senator spoke at the event, a gaggle of press several yards thick surrounded him outside the Vatican walls — leaving some to stumble under the shuffling while others were nearly trampled.

Sanders told media he has been “enormously impressed” by the pope, who he said is giving “visionary views about creating a moral economy, an economy that works for all people not just the people on top.”

The presidential hopeful particularly praised Francis recent encyclical on the environment, Laudato Si’, saying that “the fossil fuel industry is literally destroying our planet” and that countries need to invest in other technologies.

“What Pope Francis has told us, over and over again, is that we have the wealth to do that, we have the technology to do that, we have the know-how to do that,” said Sanders.

“What we have got to confront is the greed of people who are so much more concerned about their own billions than the future of our children and the future of the planet,” he said. “I am just so excited to be here, so proud to be here, with other like-minded people who are trying to do our best to create a moral economy.”

Honduran Cardinal Óscar Rodríguez Maradiaga, the coordinator of Francis’ Council of Cardinals, is also speaking, as is Fr. J. Bryan Hehir, a noted professor at Harvard’s John F. Kennedy School of Government.  Jeffrey Sachs, director of the Earth Institute at Columbia University, is also taking part and spoke alongside Sanders during the senator’s brief press conference.

Sanders began his remarks by quoting extensively from Centesimius Annus, saying the encyclical was a “clarion call for human freedom in its truest sense: freedom that defends the dignity of every person and that is always oriented towards the common good.”

“There are few places in modern thought that rival the depth and insight of the church’s moral teachings on the market economy,” said the senator.

“The challenges facing our planet are not mainly technological or even financial,” said Sanders. “Our challenge is mostly a moral one, to redirect our efforts and vision to the common good.”

Centesimus Annus, which we celebrate and reflect on today, and Laudato Si’, are powerful, eloquent and hopeful messages of this possibility,” he said. “It is up to us to learn from them, and to move boldly toward the common good in our time.”

Cross-posted with minor reductions, from Josh McElwee’s reporting

From Sr. Simone Campbell:

Catholic social justice teaching supports an economy that puts people, not profit, at the center, where each person can find a job that provides for his or her family.

I was delighted to be invited to the White House when Obama signed his executive action. There, I sat next to a low-wage worker named Robin who was wearing a beautiful blue dress. Robin beamed as she told me that she purchased the dress using her employee discount at the retail store where she worked. Robin also shared that she lived in a homeless shelter because she could not afford a place of her own on how little she earned working full-time. We were there to celebrate the good news of Obama’s action, but the awareness that women like Robin still lived in poverty left me anguished.

My conversation with Robin reminded me that every economic policy decision has moral significance. Too many people like Robin who work in low-wage jobs are robbed of the opportunity to achieve the fullness of their human potential because they cannot simply shelter or feed themselves. This is unjust.

Pope Benedict XVI affirmed the moral dimension of our economic life when he noted that “poverty results from a violation of the dignity of human work . . . because a low value is put on work and the rights that flow from it, especially the right to a just wage and to the personal security of the worker and his or her family.”

Pope Francis has taught us, “Just as the commandment ‘Thou shalt not kill’ sets a clear limit in order to safeguard the value of human life, today we also have to say ‘thou shalt not’ to an economy of exclusion and inequality. Such an economy kills.”

Until the United States enacts a living wage that allows workers to care for themselves and their families, we are complicit in perpetuating the economy of exclusion and inequality.

As the president prepares to leave the Oval Office, we can honor his legacy and ensure that we move forward in creating our vision, shared by Pope Francis, of an economy of inclusion. Not only did Obama raise the minimum wage, he followed up by using executive action to end wage theft and extend paid leave for low-wage federal contract workers.

Given that the U.S. government is America’s leading low-wage job creator — creating more poverty jobs than Wal-Mart and McDonald’s combined — Obama exemplifies how the next president can use his or her executive authority to lift workers out of poverty when Congress fails to act.

By committing to use executive action to help workers in the “Fight for $15 and a union,” the 2016 candidates can honor the full potential of human life and work. Moreover, they can shift our national conversation away from simply adjusting the minimum wage to ensuring that every person enjoys living wages and the right to organize.

Robin and millions of workers like her are counting on our elected leaders to do everything possible to ensure our government acts to create a moral economy in which they enjoy the right to live in dignity and provide for themselves and their families.

[Social Service Sr. Simone Campbell is executive director of NETWORK, a national Catholic social justice lobby, and author of A Nun on the Bus: How All of Us Can Create Hope, Change, and Community.]